Breakdown of the $50 Thrift Store Challenge

As mentioned in The Thrill Of The Hunt, fortune struck twice as I found a set of great condition Ping Eye 2 irons. I'd already had a set of MacGregor MCX irons, so I headed to X Golf in Holland to jump on their simulator and get some telemetry data comparing the two iron sets:

MacGregor MCX Distance	Club	Ping Eye 2 Distance
150	3 Iron	160
130	4 Iron	150
140	5 Iron	120
140	6 Iron	120
120	7 Iron	110
110	8 Iron	110
95	9 Iron	90
95	Wedge	100

Now, these are drastically shorter than my modern gamer set, the Ping G400. My modern Pings are substantially more consistent, with my 9 iron going on average 120, and each club getting about 10 yards farther each step up.

There are also discrepancies in the telemetry system at X Golf - I get far different results on outdoor driving ranges or on the actual course than I have at their indoor range. I've gotten far more reliable, reproducible results on Maple Hill's Launch Kitchen, for instance. But, that's far and beyond the point.

What I'm trying to get at is that I've got to make some decisions as to which iron set will actually fit into the spirit of the $50 Thrift Store Challenge. As seen above, the forged MacGregor irons generally went a bit further, had more consistent gapping between irons, and felt better overall to hit...there's truth to the old guys saying how good and pure it feels to hit a nice set of forged irons. The Pings went shorter, and had less consistent gapping between irons. While they went farther off-line left to right, they were dead consistent. The Macs were all over the place in that regard...some went left, some went straight, some went right.

Comments

Merry Christmas from Tulip City!

I don't have a full article this week, but here's a little bit of trivia for you: While Holland is a predominantly Christian Reformed city, it was the early Methodists that sprung the Christmas spirit. While an 1867 Sunday School Christmas Program drew nearly 150 youngsters to Hope Church, it was several generations before the Reformed church allowed even Christmas trees into their sanctuaries, as Christmas trees were seen as Pagan symbols. Early Methodists adopted the 19th Century American spirit, and welcomed things like Christmas trees and even Santa Claus into their sanctuaries. I tried to determine exactly how long "several generations" were using Dr. Swierenga's book (and the sources he cites), but could not ascertain the exact time. It's almost certainly somewhere in the vicinity of 50 years (before the Christian Reformed Churches allowed 'pagan' Christmas symbols), which would put their allowing of such things into the early 20th century, but ...

The Cedar Swamp Village

Holland has only been a settled city for a little over 170 years. But, it's got a dense, unique history. I took an interest in local history during my college years at Northern Michigan University, and was able to take that interest back home after graduation. Recently, I began researching for this blog, and hanging out at the library, poring through the Local History section. I found an old, forboding looking book, entitled Memorials Of The Grand River Valley, flipped open to a seemingly random page, and read the passage "The Indian village, near the southeastern limits of the city,w as also a prominent landing-place. The log-houses, built by the Indians, were of great service to the newly arrived immigrants; and, as it appears, there never has been any trouble between the Red man and the Dutchman." This piqued my interest, as I live near the southeastern limits of Holland. Was there an Indian village in my own neighborhood that history forgot? Memorials ad...

The Ghost Town in Hudsonville

When the term "ghost town" is brought up, one doesn't usually think of modern subdivisions and upper-middle class suburbs. The classic "ghost town" is usually applied to a town that was abandoned when a major industry dries up, leaving crumbling shells of buildings, maybe some artifacts, and nothing but memories. You know the drill, overgrown storefronts, smashed windows, tumbleweeds, maybe a hobo or two. Briefly, there was an interurban rail system all around Western Michigan in the late 19 th and early 20 th century. I won't go into details, as the whole system is well-documented elsewhere, but the electric train systems allowed for the transportation of people all around the major metropolitan areas in West Michigan...Grand Rapids was a major hub, and they had lines going to Grandville, Jenison, and Hudsonville along Chicago Drive; south to Kalamazoo; and as it pertains to this story, to Holland and Saugatuck. The branch between Grand Rapids an...

Tulip City Dispatch

Search This Blog